Contents5 sections
Turnover is expensive, and the usual response is a counteroffer once someone resigns, or a new perk. Giving people a stake has better evidence behind it, but it means sharing the upside.
The cost of replacing someone
Replacing an employee costs roughly a fifth of their annual salary. Heather Boushey and Sarah Jane Glynn of the Center for American Progress pooled 30 case studies from 11 research papers in There Are Significant Business Costs to Replacing Employees (2012). For every position except executives and physicians, the median replacement cost was 21 percent of annual salary. Senior people cost more: the highest estimate in the review, for very highly paid jobs and senior or executive roles, was 213 percent, more than two years' pay. If sharing the upside is what holds you back, weigh it against those figures.
A later essay, what AI leaves to people, argues that judgment gets scarcer as AI takes over routine work. If that is right, the people who exercise it get more expensive to lose.
Owners quit less and stay longer
The National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO) publishes a summary of research findings. It includes NCEO's 2023 study of S corporation ESOPs (employee stock ownership plans), in which the companies reported voluntary quit rates of roughly one third of the national average.
NCEO's 2017 report Employee Ownership and Economic Well-Being, built on Bureau of Labor Statistics data, looked at people aged 28 to 34. Employee owners in that group reported a median tenure of 5.2 years, against 3.4 years for their conventionally employed peers, or 53 percent longer.
In Employee-Owned Firms in the COVID-19 Pandemic, a survey Rutgers University ran for the Employee Ownership Foundation in October 2020, employee-owned firms were three to four times more likely than conventional peers to keep both managers and non-managers. They were also significantly less likely to cut pay or hours, which suggests that companies owned by their people try harder to keep them.
A stake or a raise
We think a stake keeps people because it gives them part of the value they help create. A perk does not do that, and a competing offer can match a raise.
The 2017 NCEO report also looked at wealth. Employee owners aged 28 to 34 had a median household net worth 92 percent higher than comparable non-owners, $28,500 against $14,831, and they earned higher wages as well. The wealth came on top of higher pay, not in place of it.
What has to come with the shares
NCEO's summary ties the gains of employee ownership to employees taking part in decisions. We think retention works the same way: a stake keeps people when holders have a say in decisions about their work and can see the company's accounts and who owns what.
Vesting matters too. A standard four-year schedule with a cliff rewards time served: leave early and you forfeit the unvested part. That does keep people, but it vests the same whether someone built anything or not. The alternative is a stake earned against contribution, vesting as the work is delivered.
Co-operatives, businesses owned by their members, have already worked through the questions you will face when you hand out a stake: who counts as a member, how members vote, how they leave. They have a settled definition and seven principles, and our essay on co-operative ownership goes through them.
Stakes in our own ventures
We try to meet those conditions by design. Operators join our ventures for equity instead of day rates, and their stakes vest against delivered work. In each venture, stakes are recorded in the same ledger as payroll, vendor payments and capital calls, and anyone holding a stake in that venture can read it and see who owns what without asking. A stake carries a vote in the mandates it is exposed to, the specific decisions handed to its holders.
That is the design. We publish no venture ledger on this site, so nothing in this paragraph can be checked from here. We got the order of setting these ventures up wrong the first time, and a later essay on incorporating them as businesses covers what went wrong and the order we follow now.
If you plan to use equity to keep your people, decide who gets a say, what holders can see and what vesting pays for before you hand out any shares.